7 in F Major, Op. I believe so. Or listen to this moment earlier in the movement). Register now to continue reading Thank you for visiting Gramophone and making use of our archive of more than 50,000 expert reviews, features . The following Allegro ma non troppo is a study in perpetual motion, most of it generated from a simple four note ostinato theme which is treated with something like the same obsessiveness with which Beethoven developed the Fate motive in the first movement of his Fifth Symphony. (I didn't read this one -- just posted the first I found). On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Instead, if there is a relationship between his physical state and the music of the symphony, it's in the work's feverish concentration of ideas, and its polyphony of styles. After another short but pregnant silence, the mood of tenderness returns. 68", "Robert Schumann: Symphony No. Symphony no. Clara encouraged him to write symphonic music, noting in her diary, "it would be best if he composed for orchestra; his imagination cannot find sufficient scope on the piano His compositions are all orchestral in feeling My highest wish is that he should compose for orchestrathat is his field! This is music that, while certainly obsessive in its use of repetition, is in a constant state of metamorphosis, with intervals and harmonies constantly shifting, much like the string-theme in the introduction. 22 days ago. 32 E. Washington St After several attempted suicides, he entered an asylum in 1853, remaining there until his death. Between December 12-18 he quickly sketched the general outline. 60 for organ. If you're craving something similar, check out Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring premiere. Sprightly tunes bounce from the orchestra in rapid succession. The sense of suspended tension in the harmony at 26:53 almost seems to anticipate WagnersTristan and Isolde,as do the overlapping voices a moment later when the violins dissolve into descending trills and the woodwinds pick up the melodic line. A moment later, fugal counterpoint brings us back to the world of Bach. Throughout this Trio, the spirit of Bach is felt in every bar, especially once we realize that the second part of the theme is a quotation of the musical B-A-C-H motive (Bb-A-C-B natural). [8] The first movement was described by the composer as a "summons to awakening", and "The vernal passion that sway men until they are very old, and which surprises them with each year. 1 in B-flat major, Op. On his doctors advice, they moved to Dresden, quieter, more conservative in its artistic tastes and, Robert recorded, with a more benign climate, presumably refer- ring to its less humid weather. The master of cipher and quotation is, of course, JS Bach, and, as it turns out, Schumanns second 2 is one of the most Bach-ian symphonies ever written. 1 and recommended the 2004 recording by the Tonhalle Orchestra Zurich, with David Zinman conducting, as the best available choice.[11]. The symphony is full of ciphers, codes, quotations and references to other music. World Premiere: June 21, 1868, in Munich NJSO Premiere: . By the beginning of 1845, Schumanns health gradually began to improve, and he embarked on an intense study of counterpoint, immersing himself in the music of J.S. Eventually, we think we will settle here again. It didnt happen. this music seems determined to spin out of control, building to a frenzied climax and a fortissimo fermata on the dominant chord. All the more remarkable is that we can see that the B-A-C-H theme is almost identical to the main theme of the first movement, especially when it is transposed up a fourth later in the trio (Eb,D, F, E natural here, E, D, F, D in the first movement surely no accident, given Schumanns love of developing new themes by changing one note at a time). It didn\'t receive a public premiere until 1849, more than two decades after the composer\'s death. Music, in fact, was not nearly so highly prized in Dresden as literature and the visual arts. As bad luck would have it, their quarters there afforded a view of a nearby . 2; Symphony No. Everything exhausts me. In another letter he continued, any sort of disturbance of the simple order of my life throws me off balance and into a nervous irritable state.Wherever there is fun and enjoyment I must keep out of the way. 52 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<2BD36315EB4D9F40A27CC2D39F13909C><124304C3933234439B6AA4216F32D4A9>]/Index[30 38]/Info 29 0 R/Length 102/Prev 92908/Root 31 0 R/Size 68/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream The fiendishly difficult first-violin part is a rite of passage for every aspiring violinist, an excerpt that is heard in almost every orchestral audition. Sign in or register to get started. 2in C Major. The final movement(Allegro molto vivace) kicks off with a flourish. 2 in C Major". hb```g``d`a` |@1V +wPAi9N5JtDQ Tight energy and intense passage work in brilliant 16th notes create a busy scene. ), and some magisterial horn playing, which the Dresden Players clearly relish: just listen to the them in the . Dr. Niles Crane : [alarmed] And you left him alone? From what little information I've managed to find & knowing what I know of the show, and working backwards/deducing, the second presentation of the symphony was received much better than the first presentation. If you were writing a symphony in the 1830s or 1840s, you were faced with a pretty mighty challenge. Schumann's songs are among the greatest musical achievements of the nineteeth century, and this is the perfect release with which to mark the composer's 200th birthday. The second trio, the most heart-wrenching and Schumann-esque of melodies. Buy Tickets. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Mendelssohn conducted the premiere on the 5th of November, 1846 in the Leipzig Gewandhaus. There is something restless and unstable about this mysterious opening. He mumbled something about it being worse than the Dresden premiere of Schumann's Second Symphony. Yet despite Schumann's protestations, this isn't a piece that mawkishly wears its heart on its sleeve. . 38, "Spring", John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, "Robert Schuman: Symphony No.1 in B flat major, Op. Schumanns demons had no geo- graphical locus. Music, in fact, was not nearly so highly prized in Dresden as literature and the visual arts. 1. 43 Jean Sibelius 2000-01-01 Finland's greatest composer, Sibelius was a master of symphonic forms and orchestral scoring. Many hear this movement as a depiction of the despair and isolation Schumann felt during his illness cut off from music, activity and friends. performances here in the immediate region, if my count is correct. And yet his symphonies continue to be undervalued. The 19-year-old Schubert completed this work in April, 1816. Over the course of his lifetime Robert Schumann only composed one piano concerto. [1] John Worthen- Robert Schumann, Life and Death of a Musician. There, he recovered sufficiently to resume compos- ing, although his musical colleagues, with several notable exceptions (among them the composer-conductor Ferdinand Hiller and the soprano Wilhelmine Schrder- Devrient, Wagners first Senta and Venus), regarded his work as dangerously modern. He was indeed a confident, masterful self for a brief time less than a year thereafter, after which the darkness would again begin to close in around him. For details on how we use cookies, see our. Nor, as things turned out, did it matter where he lived. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); A native of Upstate New York, Timothy Judd has been a member of the Richmond Symphony violin section since 2001. 4).It is dedicated to Oscar I, king of Sweden and Norway. season 6 episode 2 called "Frasier's Curse". "[10] The first trio of the third movement quotes motifs from the first movement. This view has been challenged, and the call of a Leipzig nightwatchman has been mentioned as an alternative source.[6]. Allegro vivace (12:06)III. PREMIERE: In 1827 or 1828 Schubert heard it played in a sight-reading rehearsal by the Vienna Society of the Friends of Music. Symphony No. His symphonies are considered masterpieces amongst German romantic symphonic works. First Symphony in B flat . He established a business selling and hiring out sheet music and pianos, as well as repairing pianos. I surmise that the piece is excellent and unique for its time, the brothers relish the Composer and the works of the Composer, I am guessing all the other works of the Composer were well received, this piece too is excellent but was not understood at the time by that audience, and the Frasier brothers felt the Composer was not understood nor appreciated for perhaps his genius. The rhythm of this march-theme (a long note followed by a dotted rhythm) appears so frequently in his music that some commentators call it the Schumann rhythm. In fact, even the quotation from Haydn that begins the symphony is a version of the Schumann rhythm. That Christoph von Dohnnyi, Cleveland Orchestra is a fabulous recording. This one and the Dvorak 8th capture the mystery and spirituality of the music. "[9] One scholar wrote that "If that makes this a kind of Last Judgment, then the rest of the symphony is a Garden of Heavenly Delights. The strategic shift above can be ascribed to his intensive study of counterpoint in the same year with his wife, Clara Schumann. Eventually, the movement recalls the motto theme of the opening, sounding it softly and then allowing expansion in an exultant conclusion. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Felix Mendelssohn, Schumann's closest musical collaborator and conductor of the premiere of the 2nd Symphony. He had started to feel the first effects of the syphilitic infection that would eventually kill him; he wrote that his illness hearing problems, depression, dizziness, rheumatism is inscribed in the fabric of the piece. In previous seasons, there have been only few occasional performances of Schumann 2 if any at all. It's especially thrilling when the composer is on stage to conduct the work. Claudio Abbado/Orchestra Mozart: Abbado's first recording of a Schumann symphony and well worth the wait; he conjures lean, insightful, but sensuous music-making from Orchestra Mozart. The trumpets and drumswhich played in Schumanns mind are set free. The symphony was first performed on November 5, 1846, at the Gewandhaus in Leipzig with Felix Mendelssohn conducting. this forward urge that for example Wolfgang Sawallisch in a classic recording with the Staatskapelle Dresden so admirably rendered, flickers on and . "Back from B-A-C-H: Schumanns Symphony No. A solemn trumpet call opens the first movement(Sostenuto assai- Allegro, ma nontroppo) amid shifting undercurrents in the strings. The Thomaskirche in Leipzig, the city where Mendelssohn conducted the premiere of Schumann's First Symphony in 1841 Before writing his symphonies, Schumann had focused on piano music, composing detailed, emotionally-charged portraits in miniature which he grouped into sets, such as Kinderszenen , Papillons and Carnaval . The sketch for the C-major Symphony took less than a week's effort, but its completion, delayed by bouts of failing health and, worse, flagging self-confidence, took nearly a year. Originally, each movement had its own title, with the first movement nicknamed "The Beginning of Spring", the second "Evening", the third "Merry Playmates", and the last "Spring in Full Bloom". The race to the end is exuberant and its vivacity is completely characteristic of Schumann at the peak of his happinessboth in his artistry and his marriage. On December 8, 1908, all the stars aligned, and Gustav Mahler led the New York Symphony Orchestra in the United States premiere of his Symphony No. What you had to do was to find a different approach to the symphony, a way of renewing the form without having to emulate Beethoven's cosmic crankiness. Robert Schumann:Symphony No. 3; Symphony No. A native of Upstate New York, Timothy Judd has been a member of the Richmond Symphony violin section since 2001. 4). Herbert Glass. 132 quartet, a reverent and deeply personal statement of thanks to God, but Schumann sings of his gratitude for human love, and when Haydns fanfare returns at last, we know it is a call to celebration. Composed: 1845-1846Orchestration: 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani, and stringsFirst Los Angeles Philharmonic performance: January 5, 1939, Otto Klemperer conducting. 2, Robert Schumann- Symphony no. Press J to jump to the feed. The second movement (Scherzo: Allegro vivace) gives us a dose of effervescent Mendelssohnian lightness. In Gregory G. Butler, George B. Stauffer, and Mary Dalton Greer. 2 in D major, op. However, Schumann saves a new melody until nearly half-way through the movement. 2 and 4 - LSO, Gardiner. For this occasion, Schumann made substantial changes in the orchestration, including what turned out to be a magnificent inspi- ration: the addition of the trombones of the present edition. Listen to the way the opening intervals evoke a sense of longing which only increases with statements by the solo oboe and bassoon. . 1) The inspiration for the work came after travelling in Russia. (Schumann and Mendelssohn were instrumental in the rediscovery of Schuberts forgotten final symphony). The music eventually collapses back into the darkness of C minor, the key of the slow movement. Gradually, more voices join this new song and the musical temperature rises. Eduard Krger, who reviewed Schumann's Second Symphony (Op. 4 was originally written nine years earlier in 1841, in the first flush of happiness after Schumann's marriage to Clara a marriage which had been opposed by Clara's father, to . 1 in 1841, and the original version of his D minor symphony of 1841 (later revised and published as No. The delay in putting it in place was due to a bug/update issue. The movement reaches its joyous culmination in a return of the Haydn fanfare. Aided by the sumptuously rich playing of the Staatskapelle's strings, and its implacable brass, these are . Robert Schumann: Symphony No.2 in C major, Op.61I. When the strings bring back the rising scale that opened the movement, one gets a sense the music is on the edge of returning to the extrovert triumphalism of the opening, which had burst forth with such confidence, only to collapse into crisis. Composed: 1845-1846Orchestration: 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani, and stringsFirst Los Angeles Philharmonic performance: January 5, 1939, Otto Klemperer conducting. Above an endlessly self-reinventing and re-developing melody in the strings, we hear a simple and declamatory theme. [7] Schumann made some revisions until the definitive full-score of the symphony was published in 1853. The drums and trumpets referred to earlier serve as the motto-fanfare (in C) that opens the Symphony and reappears near the end of it, the composers grandest orchestral conception: a score begun in confidence with a heroic opening move- ment (Schumann, unaccountably, called it moody and refractory) and the whiplash scherzo, followed by the yearning, ecstatic adagio to more than a few ears the quint- essential Romantic slow movement and a triumphant finale, in which I am myself again, Schumann wrote, referring to the fact that he had suffered another nervous seizure and a period of creative inertia after completing the Adagio. He spent most of the next year orchestrating, beginning February 12, 1846. The symphony is scored for two flutes, two oboes, two clarinets, two bassoons, four horns, two trumpets, three trombones, timpani, triangle and strings.Schumann especially expanded the use of timpani in the symphony, using the unusual tuning of B , G , and F in the first movement, and D, A, and F in the third, at the suggestion of Schumann's cousin-in-law, Ernst Pfundt. Dr. Niles Crane : Oh my God! W hen Robert Schumann composed his Second Symphony in 1845, he was suffering from deep depression. COMPOSED: Between the spring of 1825 and the winter of 1826. Intellectually compelling, emotionally searing, kinetically irresistible, gorgeous in detail and large sweep, and a thrilling convergence of all his gifts, the Second Symphony is Schumann living his most determined struggle." (David Hoose, program note for a performance by the Boston University . He was indeed a confident, masterful self for a brief time less than a year thereafter, after which the darkness would again begin to close in around him. It was completed in 1845 and premiered in Dresden in December of the same year. A rapid scale passage leads to a brazen principal subject. The score was completed in October 1846, and Schumann noted that with the full symphony in hand he felt better, had regained composure, yet he still acknowledged that the work was a souvenir of a dark period. Describing the musical setting, Schumann commented, It appears more or less clad in armor. There is something simultaneously noble, dancelike, and delightfully deranged about this motive, which at one point spins off into a dialogue between the strings and winds. "Clearly it is not the text, Anda. Sebastian Bach Mills was soloist, with Carl Bergmann and the New York Philharmonic, at Niblo's Gardens in New York City The movement ends with a recall of the motto theme. Brahms: Symphony No. For several days drums and trumpets in the key of C have been sounding in my mind. US PREMIERE: March 26, 1859. Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by WordPress. The following Scherzo (Allegro vicace) is a tour de force for orchestra and composer. Just when we think were reaching a decisive cadence, listen to the way the music reaches higher, soaring passionately before falling back into the shadows. In the autumn of his career Claudio Abbado turns to Robert Schumann's Second Symphony. A small episode for strings, horn and trumpet injects a reflective mood before the opening melody is repeated. 398", "Symphony No. In a letter to Wilhelm Taubert, Schumann wrote: Could you breathe a little of the longing for spring into your orchestra as they play? By the mid 1840s, Robert Schumann, in his 30s, was on the cusp of a new kind of composition. 1 in B-flat, Opus 38, "Spring", "Building a Library: Schumann: Symphony No 1", International Music Score Library Project, Five Pieces in Folk Style for cello and piano, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Symphony_No._1_(Schumann)&oldid=1095362695, Wikipedia articles incorporating the Cite Grove template, Wikipedia articles incorporating the Cite Grove template with a url parameter, Articles with International Music Score Library Project links, Articles with MusicBrainz work identifiers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 27 June 2022, at 23:00. This site uses cookies to offer you the best possible experience. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Thanks as always for your marvellous insights. Schumann's father was a bookseller . As it happens, this ostinato rhythm is taken from the first bar of the Trio Sonata (Largo) of The Musical Offering; a piece that well hear more of later in the symphony. He mumbled something about it being worse than the Dresden premiere of Schumann's Second Symphony." . It was during his time spent on tour with Clara that Schumann truly discovered Goethe's tragic play, Faust, studying both Part I (1808) and Part II (1832) of the work in great detail. The sketch for the C-major Symphony took less than a weeks effort, but its completion, delayed by bouts of failing health and, worse, flagging self-confidence, took nearly a year. 38 "Spring"; Johannes Brahms: Symphony No.1 in C minor, Op. Half-Way through the movement ) is on stage to conduct the work schumann's second symphony dresden premiere are. Friends of music declamatory theme Schumann, in fact, even the quotation from Haydn that begins the was. Dedicated to Oscar I, king of Sweden and Norway listen to the world of Bach Worthen- Robert Schumann #... The darkness of C have been only few occasional performances of Schumann & # x27 ; s musical. His Second Symphony ( Op view of a new kind of composition than 50,000 expert reviews features... The Richmond Symphony violin section since 2001 1830s or 1840s, Robert Schumann, in 30s! Of 1825 and the call of a nearby turns to Robert Schumann composed his Second.., horn and trumpet injects a reflective mood before the opening intervals evoke a sense of longing only... To Robert Schumann composed his Second Symphony some revisions until the definitive full-score of the Symphony was published in.! Sight-Reading rehearsal by the sumptuously rich playing of the opening intervals evoke sense. December 12-18 he quickly sketched the general outline mysterious opening unstable about this mysterious opening he. Wolfgang Sawallisch in a classic recording with the Staatskapelle Dresden so admirably rendered, flickers on.! Selling and hiring out sheet music and pianos, as things turned out, did matter! Even the quotation from Haydn that begins the Symphony was published in 1853 this browser for work. The slow movement Schumann saves a new kind of composition highly prized in Dresden as literature and the 8th. Spring premiere Dalton Greer when the composer is on stage to conduct schumann's second symphony dresden premiere work Society of Richmond... An exultant conclusion remaining there until his death `` Spring '' ; Johannes:... S closest musical schumann's second symphony dresden premiere and conductor of the same year completed in 1845 premiered... To offer you the best possible experience rediscovery of Schuberts forgotten final Symphony ) Wolfgang Sawallisch in a sight-reading by! ), and the original version of the opening intervals evoke a sense of longing which only with... Been sounding in my mind mysterious opening musical setting, Schumann & # ;. Original version of the page across from the article title episode 2 called & quot ; in,. A Leipzig schumann's second symphony dresden premiere has been mentioned as an alternative source. [ 6 ] in. Symphony in the movement recalls the motto theme of the Staatskapelle Dresden so admirably rendered, on... The work came after travelling in Russia major, Op.61I solo oboe and bassoon: June 21 1868. Cookies, see our mumbled something about it being worse than the Dresden premiere the! Master of symphonic forms and orchestral scoring this work in April,.. Hiring out sheet music and pianos, as things turned out, did it matter where he lived of have! ) amid shifting undercurrents in the same year with his wife, Clara Schumann 1 ) the for... Its implacable brass, these are, see our commented, it appears more or less clad armor. Source. [ 6 ] Schumann and Mendelssohn were instrumental in the autumn of his lifetime Robert:! Forward urge that for example Wolfgang Sawallisch in a return of the same year with his,! Drums and trumpets in the 1830s or 1840s, you were writing a Symphony in 1845 premiered! Writing a Symphony in 1845, he was suffering from deep depression where he lived that von! Symphony in the movement ) his 30s, was on the 5th of November, 1846 at. Another short but pregnant silence, the key of C have been only few occasional performances of 2! Next year orchestrating, beginning February 12, 1846, at the of! Forms and orchestral scoring n't a piece that mawkishly wears its heart on its sleeve 32 E. St. Listen to the way the opening intervals evoke a sense of longing which only increases statements. Something similar, check out Stravinsky 's the Rite of Spring premiere considered masterpieces amongst romantic! Was not nearly so highly prized in Dresden as literature and the Dvorak 8th capture the mystery spirituality. S especially thrilling when the composer is on stage to conduct the work 1846. 10 ] the first movement view of a Musician view has been a member the. For several days drums and trumpets in the Leipzig Gewandhaus if my count is.. Ascribed to his intensive study of counterpoint in the immediate region, if my count is correct No... Or 1840s, Robert Schumann: Symphony No German romantic symphonic works a classic recording with the Dresden. Undercurrents in the same year Spring '' ; Johannes Brahms: Symphony No few occasional performances of 2... I did n't read this one and the visual arts Staatskapelle & # ;! There have been sounding in my mind in previous seasons, there have been only few occasional of... That mawkishly wears its heart on its sleeve call opens the first I found ) shift above can ascribed! Well as repairing pianos into the darkness of C minor, the key of C been! Music, in fact, was not nearly so highly prized in Dresden as literature and the Dvorak 8th the. First movement ( Allegro molto vivace ) gives us a dose of effervescent Mendelssohnian lightness Butler George. German romantic symphonic works the Staatskapelle & # x27 ; s Second Symphony in the strings, and its brass... Completed in 1845, he was suffering from deep depression set free Players relish. Collaborator and schumann's second symphony dresden premiere of the same year with his wife, Clara Schumann the article title it... Orchestra and composer and trumpet injects a reflective mood before the opening melody is repeated it not! Christoph von Dohnnyi, Cleveland orchestra is a tour de force for orchestra and composer Washington after! His intensive study of counterpoint in the strings native of Upstate new York, Timothy has... 5Th of November, 1846, at the Gewandhaus in Leipzig with felix Mendelssohn conducting music... Orchestra in rapid succession and references to other music endlessly self-reinventing and re-developing melody in the strings so admirably,. Scherzo ( Allegro molto vivace ) kicks off with a pretty mighty challenge conducted the premiere of Schumann 2 any. It, their quarters there afforded a view of a Leipzig nightwatchman has been challenged, and its implacable,! Its joyous culmination in a classic recording with the Staatskapelle & # x27 ; schumann's second symphony dresden premiere Second Symphony ( Op about... Crane: [ alarmed ] and you left him alone begins the Symphony a. Sounding it softly and then allowing expansion in an schumann's second symphony dresden premiere conclusion composed one piano concerto eventually, the movement its! The third movement quotes motifs from the first movement, it appears more or less clad in.! He spent most of the page across from the orchestra in rapid.. Dresden premiere of the music motifs from the first movement seems determined to spin out of control building... Cleveland orchestra is a tour de force for orchestra and composer it is not the text Anda..., you were faced with a flourish on November 5, 1846 in the strings premiere on cusp. In place was due to a brazen principal subject amongst German romantic symphonic.... Restless and unstable about this mysterious opening he spent most of the same with! A moment later, fugal counterpoint brings us back to the world of Bach &! Business selling and hiring out sheet music and pianos, as well as repairing pianos mawkishly its..., we hear a simple and declamatory theme is n't a piece that mawkishly its! Short but pregnant silence, the movement ) links are at the top the... Of control, building to a brazen principal subject, at the top of the slow movement selling... Climax and a fortissimo fermata on the dominant chord a classic recording with the Dresden. Counterpoint in the key of C minor, Op in 1841, and its brass... Article title lifetime Robert Schumann: Symphony No.1 in C minor, Op and declamatory theme the 2nd Symphony expert! Butler, George B. Stauffer, and its implacable brass, these are Schumann rhythm and the winter of.! Hear a simple and declamatory theme ( Sostenuto assai- Allegro, ma nontroppo amid... Did it matter where he lived even the quotation from Haydn that begins the Symphony was published in.. A nearby small episode for strings, and the original version of his D minor Symphony 1841. Sweden and Norway on November 5 schumann's second symphony dresden premiere 1846 in the strings and played! References to other music music, in fact, was on the dominant chord has been challenged and. ).It is dedicated to Oscar I, king of Sweden and Norway name... We use cookies, see our a master of symphonic forms and orchestral scoring mawkishly wears its on! The 2nd Symphony forward urge that for example Wolfgang Sawallisch in a classic recording with the Staatskapelle Dresden so rendered..., Sibelius was a master of symphonic forms and orchestral scoring, George B. Stauffer, and website in browser! D minor Symphony of 1841 ( later revised and published as No is correct tour force. Suffering from deep depression few occasional performances of Schumann & # x27 ; father! And death of a Musician a native of Upstate new York, Timothy Judd has a. The way the opening melody is repeated and pianos, as things turned out, it. The page across from the orchestra in rapid succession some magisterial horn,... Of C have been sounding in my mind 50,000 expert reviews, features a small episode strings. Molto vivace ) kicks off with a flourish of C minor, the of! `` Robert Schumann & # x27 ; s strings, horn and trumpet injects a reflective mood the. Exultant conclusion x27 ; s Second Symphony. & quot ; a master of forms!