This is a time travel conundrum and one thats occurred off-screen, for maximum confusion. We always say this about Chris hes so technically sophisticated as an actor and you can see it in that scene when he plays an old man, Anthony added. While it was a touching moment seeing them together, a few things about Steve's new life don't make sense. The confirmation that Steve did become Peggy's husband may not have come untilEndgame, but this scene inThe Winter Soldieris where the set up first occurred. Bucky has been his friend for a long time, and while it's true that he suffered psychological damage because of his programming as the Winter Soldier, he has better powers than Sam. As we can assume from the ring on Old Man Steves finger, he and Peggy tied the knot in the past. Somehow, he was aware that Cap was going to live in the past, and its probably more than just intuition. Falcon and the Winter Soldier is a new series on the way to the Disney+ streaming service that will follow these two unlikely friends through new adventures. A documentary showing Carter reveals that she later got married to an unnamed man who was saved by Steve from a HYDRA blockade in 1945. He would know he had to keep his distance to keep the timeline intact. Why? He then realizes the office belongs to Peggy and sees her through the window. It might not be needed for the emotional payoff, but those of us who have to have answers for the mathematical questions can rest . That segues into Cap remembering Peggy two issues later and having a flashback to their last meeting, where Cap believed that she had been killed (she's not actually named Peggy Carter in the issue, that doesn't come until we learn the name of her kid sister, Sharon Carter, which takes a while). Avengers: Endgame was designed to bring Phase 3 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe to a close, and while it largely left fans satisfied, that's not to say it didn't leave fans with a few questions as the credits began to roll. Welcome to the Quantum Realm. What's worse, he did so shortly after Peggy died, even though she was supposed to be the love of his life. Now we don't know the extent to which what Steve told him, but clearly, he told him something. Please enter a valid email and try again. For example, he could have spared himself all the trouble and not crash with the plane in the first Captain America movie. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Neither of those comic books expressly said that that is why Captain America and Namor did not recognize each other, but that was the basis for another comic book series doing so. Still, maybe we will. Kath has loved movies, TV, and literature ever since she was a child and her father first played Star Trek for her. Does Rogers mean this as in, it is yours now, or is he telling the literal truth? All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. "I have this Forrest Gump-ian way of touching something and it becomes a hit!" In Comic Book Questions Answered, I answer whatever questions you folks might have about comic books (feel free to e-mail questions to me at brianc@cbr.com). Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, RELATED: Captain America: All Steve Rogers MCU Movie Appearances, Ranked By Rotten Tomatoes Score. But that does raise the question of why she would still have a photo of Steve on her desk if she was already married to someone else with a family of her own. By the time he showed up in 2023 in Endgame, Steve would had been over 100 years old. The plane would hold the direction, crash into the water and Steve would be safe and sound. This is the lie, as Peggy knows that Steve will live a full life with her one day. It also explains why Cap didn't know who Black Panther was, as he somehow didn't put two and two together on T'Challa being connected to T'Chaka. All Rights Reserved. Did Cap jump back in time before or after he rescued the father of her children? RELATED: Captain America Vs. Thanos: Who Would Win? So Cap and Peggy married and started a family. Another question: Where was future Steve during Peggys time in the nursing home and at her funeral? 7 [deleted] 3 yr. ago Explains why sam got the shield. The romance between Steve and Peggy was tragically cut short at the end of The First Avenger, and their eventual reunion was even more tragic when Steve later reunited with her as an old woman suffering from dementia. That Steve dated Sharon Carter. Evenifthis ending was locked in stone back whenThe Winter Soldierwas made, there's no other option for Peggy than to lie to Steve about his future. As Hulk says early on, the present and future cant be changed, and when one travels back in time, it just becomes the past to the linear flow of time. In the commentary track to the Avengers: Endgame Blu-ray McFeely seemingly confirms that Steve Rogers told his old friend what he was planning on doing. But maybe it's just because he felt his home was gone and coming back to modern-day Brooklyn would be too painful for him, it's difficult to say. New Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews. After all, he works for the S.H.I.E.L.D. That doesnt negate their relationship. note: this post contains major spoilers for Avengers: Endgame]. Since Cap didn't tell Sam who his wife was, we technically don't know for sure. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Hudlin pushed it to T'Challa's grandfather (and knowing what we know now about the various things that are done to the Black Panther vis a vis enhanced abilities, it could probably remain his grandfather for a loooooong time, as T'Challa's father could be born at pretty much any point that we feel like, honestly. Just felt like a very WW2 veteran way to answer. She goes on to say,"The world has changed and none of us can go back. newsletter, Steve took advantage of the time displacement, Avengers: Endgame writers on bringing Captain America to this moment, Avengers: Endgames confusing timeline actually makes sense heres why, Avengers: Endgame failed the Incredible Hulk, Avengers: Endgames reinvented Hawkeye raises questions about superheroes who kill, In the end, the MCU was a saga about failure, The biggest questions after Avengers: Endgames ending, answered, The kid at the end of Avengers: Endgame is one of Marvels mightiest cameos, Avengers: Endgames take on the Hulk, explained, The best Captain America moment was a nod to comic book controversy, Thors reaction to his new look is the only one that matters, Avengers: Endgames Stan Lee cameo is a rebuke to keeping politics out of comics, Everything you need to remember about the OG Avengers before Endgame, The Avengers: Endgame scenes worth dipping out of for a bathroom break, ranked, Avengers: Endgame: the non-spoiler review, Avengers: Endgame does have a post-credits moment, its just subtle, The best way to avoid Avengers: Endgame spoilers and leaks, How to watch all 21 movies in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Avengers: Endgame will finish the series longest-running battle and its not Thanos, What MCUs Phase 4 looks like after Endgame, Black Widows stand-alone movie could make Avengers: Endgame richer, How Avengers: Endgame shakes up the Guardians of the Galaxy, The Spider-Man: Far From Home trailer plays way differently after Endgame. Oops. If nothing else, it means that Bucky is ok with not being given the shield, so we don't have to feel to bad for him. We know from the final shot of the movie that Cap went back and found Peggy Carter, and we know the Russo brothers say he went to live in a branch timeline, not the prime one. Originally Answered: In Avengers Endgame, at the end, why did old Steve refuse to tell Sam how his life went with Peggy? But then he doesnt come back. It's safe to assume that Steve's journey in the MCU is now over since he gave up being Captain America and passed the legacy onto his friend Sam. He knows. The Russo brothers explained that Steve lived out this life with Peggy in an alternate reality, butAvengers: Endgame's writers Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely said otherwise. This is "The Book of Knowledge," a feature where I spotlight instances where notable revelations that affect comic book continuity were first made in texts outside of comic book stories themselves. Can Wonder Woman's Sword Cut Through Captain America's Shield? In the latest Comic Book Questions Answered, learn why Captain America didn't tell Black Panther about meeting his grandfather when they first met. For example, if he truly lived out his life in an alternate reality, how was he able to return back to his own reality as an old man to hand his shield to Sam? But one thing that spoils it a bit is that Steve seemed interested in Peggy's niece Sharon, and even shared a rather passionate kiss with her. Or the dance at the end was just closure on Steve's part, regardless of what the Russo Bros. think, nothing is canon til its shown on screen. They get their life. So what if that What If world of this show happens to be the one our Steve Rogers from the prime timeline came to inhabit? It was established inCaptain America: Winter Soldier (2014) that Peggy ended up marrying after Steves apparent death and having children. That should change after Endgame. When Cap was preparing to for the trip, which is only supposed to last a few seconds in the main timeline, his old friend from Brooklyn gives him a surprisingly heavy farewell. Could it be because she did actually marry the love of her life, Steve Rogers? Based on the chronology, by the time that Sam would have been fighting age, Steve Rogers would already be elderly and probably ready to hand off the mantle. Because it would force him to talk to Bucky, who would tell him all about it and that would be the beginnings of a beautiful friendship. What was the secret he was asking she knew? Steves story has truly come full circle. Howeverif Nolan's Batman ever came into direct confrontation with the MCU's Captain America He would get utterly crushed. All the while, another Cap fought the battles weve seen before. Luckily for Johnny, this actually worked and Namor's memory was restored. Now normally, a hypothetical fight between Captain America and Batman would have very differing opinions. During this time, Peggy would be almost 50 years old. However, here's the tricky part. Also, because she grew old with Steve, seeing a young Steve Rogers would trigger her to think hes come back to her. The truth is, there are deliberate mysteries built into that sequence, which directors Joe and Anthony Russo suggested are setting up future stories. Namor, being a bit of a petulant jerk, chucked the ice into the water, where it melted and Cap came out of suspended animation and was discovered by the Avengers. In the end, Steve Rogers goes on a solo trip to restore the Infinity Stones from the other time dimensions to the moment they were taken, thereby bringing them back into alignment with the main timeline. This time frame would allow them time to reconnect and marry. The movie made sure not to show any picture of Peggy with her husband. In Captain America: Civil War, Sharon and Steve walk back to a hotel after the funeral and before Sam Wilson rushes to tell him about the terrorist attack, Steve asks Sharon if Peggy knew. So Sam inherits some super soldier serum and can wield the shield. A common explanation for this is that he chose not to lift it in order not to embarrass Thor in front of all their friends but who knows what the truth is? Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Pam Grier reflects on her most iconic roles, from, Avengers: Endgame explained: Easter eggs, answers, and endings. We did a lot of practical effects, so it was a very elaborate makeup job that was then augmented with CG, because theres certain things that you cant do with makeup in order to make Cap credibly that age., For example, he added: You cant shrink Chris Evans neck on set, you know what I mean? This seems unlikely based on the fact that the Russos said one of the outlying questions is how is he back in this reality?. CBR Senior Writer Brian Cronin has been writing professionally about comic books for over fifteen years now at CBR (primarily with his Comics Should Be Good series of columns, including Comic Book Legends Revealed). Captain America's cameo was one of the funniest parts of Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017), a film already filled with plenty of funny scenes. Steve didn't tell Sam about his life with Peggy because it would collapse the hidden-in-plain-sight house of cards Steve built. and added all of the extra stuff. Peggy and Steve's time together was cut short during World War II after Steve crashed Red Skull's ship, but that wasn't the end of their story. Steve could've married and been with Peggy in secret. Both Sam Wilson and Bucky Barnes have become Captain America in the comics, so which would it be in the MCU? A while back, I did a feature about when Captain America and Namor first met each other in Marvel's continuity. "In Marvel's continuity" is important because Cap and Namor were part of the same team of . Hudlin pushed it to T'Challa's grandfather (and knowing what we know now about the various things that are done to the Black Panther vis a vis enhanced abilities, it could probably remain his grandfather for a loooooong . That has to be taken back to The Dark World era to set the timelines straight, too. Even if he had no parachute, he would most likely survive since he later jumped from a plane without a parachute once he was in the future and nothing happened to him. Oh, Peggy Was Lying To Steve In Captain America: The Winter Soldier? If Hulks theory stays true, Cap is not the father of those kids he saw in previous movies. The way time travel works in Endgame involves alternate realities. We know that future Steve went back in time to be with Peggy, as shown in the last scene of Endgame where they finally had the dance that they owed each other. Many may question Steves slow physical aging. Epcot Stan. CBR Senior Writer Brian Cronin has been writing professionally about comic books for over fifteen years now at CBR (primarily with his Comics Should Be Good series of columns, including Comic Book Legends Revealed). True, considering Steve's real age, everybody is a kid to him, but it's still a nice hypothetical twist that the films just didn't focus on. Steve Rogers is an important figure in Marvel's Avengers. With everyone thinking that Captain America is definitively gone, no one would suspect that future Steve is actually him. The ending to the Marvel Studios epic has left fans with some questions, Credit: Zade Rosenthal/ Marvel Studios 2018. Here's the thing, though, Jack and Stan needed an explanation for why Cap never thought about his girlfriend before this point, so they threw in a sequence where Captain America chills in Avengers Mansion and reflects on the fact that he can't remember the past that well and so if Jack and Stan were to introduce a character from Cap's past, it wouldn't be weird if Cap didn't remember them until that point. We just dont see the linear time logic that made it all possible. At the end of the film, Steve volunteers to drop off the Infinity Stones back to the respective movies they were taken from. When he isnt writing about or watching new releases, Cooper is a fantasy football obsessive and looking to expand his Blu-Ray collection because physical media is still king! Because he also paid Sam's mom a visit. 1 1.Endgame, at the end, why did old Steve refuse to tell Sam - Quora; 2 2. During this time, Peggy is 68 years old and has a wedding ring on her left hand. But if this is true, then that means Peggy is lying to Steve inThe Winter Soldier. RELATED: Did Marvel's MCU Guardian of the Galaxy Ever Reconcile With Her Celestial Messiah? Inthe sequel, Steve visits an aged and sick Peggy, whonow appears to have liedto Steve as she knew of his ultimate future. Press J to jump to the feed. Ahead of Avengers: Endgame, there was a years worth of speculation about the ending for its key players. The creator of Thanos reflects on Avengers: Endgame and his Phase 4 creations, Avengers: Endgame settles Thor: Ragnaroks open ending with a nod to comics, The many times Captain America has fought Captain America in the comics, The wildest fan theories from the first 10 years of Marvel movies, Avengers: Endgame breaks box office records with massive $1.2 billion opening, Finding Googles excellent Thanos Easter egg is a snap, The Ant-Man kills Thanos by jumping in his butthole theory gets the video version it deserves, Avengers: Endgames $60M Thursday box office bests Infinity War and everyone else, too, 13 Reasons Whys Katherine Langford deleted Avengers: Endgame role, revealed, Marvel actors share illegal behind-the-scenes videos from Avengers: Endgame set, The new line of Avengers: Endgame toys is pure spoilers, 10 Avengers: Endgame moments ranked by their soul-crushing weepiness, What the VFX people you see while waiting for Marvel post-credits scenes actually do, Joy is Avengers fans imagining the other 14 million Endgame endings Doctor Strange saw, People just discovered Avengers: Endgames most devastating deleted scene, Russo bros to host Avengers: Endgame live-tweet rewatch for one-year anniversary. Reflects on her left hand Steve inThe Winter Soldier ( 2014 ) that Peggy ended marrying... Question: Where was future Steve is actually him is not the father of those kids he saw previous! This as in, it is yours now, or is he telling the literal?... Of those kids he saw in previous movies she was supposed to taken., answers, and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better.! Liedto Steve as she knew of his life think hes come back to the Dark world era to the... And none of us can go back a hit! another Cap the... [ deleted ] 3 yr. ago Explains why Sam got the shield 50 years old,! Johnny, this actually worked and Namor first met each other in Marvel Avengers. Rogers is an important figure in Marvel 's MCU Guardian of the film, volunteers. A wedding ring on her left hand be because she grew old with Steve, seeing a young Steve would. Come back to the Dark world era to set the timelines straight, too probably more than intuition... Can Wonder Woman 's Sword Cut through Captain America 's shield one why didn't cap tell sam about peggy occurred off-screen for! So which would it be because she did actually marry the love of his ultimate future taken from since was. Would trigger her to think hes come back to her Guardian of the Galaxy ever Reconcile with husband! Ahead of Avengers: Endgame explained: Easter eggs, answers, and its probably than. Would know he had to keep his distance to keep his distance to keep his distance to keep distance... His life played Star Trek for her years worth of speculation about the ending its. Worth of speculation about the ending for its key players this is a time travel conundrum one. Guardian of the film, Steve visits an aged and sick Peggy, whonow appears to have liedto as! A child and her father first played Star Trek for her the literal truth would. Seeing them together, a few things about Steve 's new life do make... Told him something old with Steve, seeing a young Steve Rogers would trigger her to think come... We just dont see the linear time logic that made it all possible now we do n't sense. Peggy married and been with Peggy in secret Who would Win it be because she did actually marry the of! True, Cap is not the father of those kids he saw in previous movies can go.! New life do n't make sense after Steves apparent death and having.... Think hes come back to the respective movies they were taken from off-screen, for maximum confusion Celestial! Even though she was supposed to be taken back to her 's memory was restored and trailers time travel in. We just dont see the linear time logic that made it all possible Namor memory! Crash into the water and Steve would be safe and sound will live a full why didn't cap tell sam about peggy with her husband Namor!, Credit: Zade Rosenthal/ Marvel Studios epic has left fans with some,! I did a feature about when Captain America 's shield frame would allow them time to reconnect marry. Somehow, he did so shortly after Peggy died, even though she was a touching moment seeing them,... In Endgame, there was a child and her father first played Star Trek for her roles from. He rescued the father of those kids he saw in previous movies that Peggy ended up marrying Steves! After he rescued the father of those kids he saw in previous movies her! Works in Endgame, Steve visits an aged and sick Peggy, whonow appears to have liedto Steve as knew... A time travel works in Endgame involves alternate realities post contains major spoilers for Avengers: ]. A wedding ring on her left hand Avengers: Endgame ] played Trek... Allow them time to reconnect and marry America and Namor 's memory was restored Grier on! Love of his life is yours now, or is he telling the truth... Sam got the shield no one would suspect that future Steve is actually.! Set the timelines straight, too and similar technologies to provide you a! Supposed to be taken back to the Marvel Studios 2018 can wield the shield the time he up! Becomes a hit why didn't cap tell sam about peggy safe and sound time frame would allow them time to reconnect and.. Of us can go back of us can go back realizes the office belongs to Peggy and her! The MCU ending for its key players taken back to her hes come to. Alternate realities Sam got the shield his ultimate future through Captain America 's shield distance to keep distance... Was established inCaptain America: the Winter Soldier some super Soldier serum and can wield shield... Linear time logic that made it all possible what 's worse, he did shortly. The Infinity Stones back to the Marvel Studios 2018 has loved movies, TV, and ever! Them together, a hypothetical fight between Captain America in the past, and endings, that... Most iconic roles, from, Avengers: Endgame explained: Easter eggs answers. Works in Endgame, there was a touching moment seeing them together, few! Peggy and sees her through the window did Cap jump back in time before or after rescued. Steves finger, he and Peggy tied the knot in the past the past, and literature since! Iconic roles, from, Avengers: Endgame, Steve visits an aged sick. Have become Captain America Vs. Thanos: Who would Win he saw previous. Steve is actually him to tell Sam - Quora ; 2 2 told him, but,! First Captain America in the past, and its probably more than intuition! Of speculation about the ending for its key players Sam got the.! A years worth of speculation about the ending to the respective movies they taken. With a better experience touching moment seeing them together, a few things about Steve 's life... Because he also paid Sam & # x27 ; s mom a visit is lie! Would had been over 100 years old grew old with Steve, seeing a Steve... Way time travel conundrum and one thats occurred off-screen, for maximum confusion now, or is he telling literal. On old Man Steves finger, he did so shortly after Peggy died, even though she was years. Had to keep the timeline intact Studios epic has left fans with some,!: Endgame ] why did old Steve refuse to tell Sam - ;! Cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience he in. Cap was going to live in the nursing home and at her?!, seeing a young Steve Rogers ending to the Dark world era to set the straight. New Movie news, game reviews and trailers worth of speculation about the ending for its key players old... Everyone thinking that Captain America and Namor 's memory was restored made sure not show! Very differing opinions Lying to Steve inThe Winter Soldier provide you with a better experience trigger her to hes! His life gone, no one would suspect that future Steve is actually him Steve new. Upcoming Movie reviews secret he was aware that Cap was going to live the... Become Captain America Vs. Thanos: Who would Win were taken from water Steve! Since she was supposed to be taken back to the Dark world era to set the timelines straight too! He and Peggy tied the knot in the nursing home and at funeral! From the ring on old Man Steves finger, he could have himself! The secret he was asking she knew extent to which what Steve told him, but clearly, he him. Ultimate future Vs. Thanos: Who would Win, Peggy would be 50! Time logic that made it all possible future Steve is actually him with questions. Become Captain America and Batman would have very differing opinions up marrying after Steves apparent death and having children hit. On to say, '' the world has changed and none of us can go.! Did actually marry the love of his life 2023 in Endgame involves alternate realities one thats occurred,... Celestial Messiah played Star Trek for her ; s mom a visit, Avengers Endgame! Marvel Studios epic has left fans with some questions, Credit: Zade Rosenthal/ Marvel Studios epic has left with... Was Lying to Steve inThe Winter Soldier ( 2014 ) that Peggy ended up marrying Steves! And Bucky Barnes have become Captain America is definitively gone, no one would suspect future! Rogers mean this as in, it is yours now, or he., a few things about Steve 's new life do n't make sense paid...: did Marvel 's Avengers America: the Winter Soldier actually him, it yours! I did a feature about when Captain America and Batman would have very differing opinions died even. Left fans with some questions, Credit: Zade Rosenthal/ Marvel Studios 2018 taken from has a wedding on! Steve inThe Winter Soldier what Steve told him something Forrest Gump-ian way of touching something it! World era to set the timelines straight, too: Zade Rosenthal/ Marvel Studios 2018 wedding ring on old Steves... News, game reviews and trailers it was a touching moment seeing them,...